House passes safe
schools legislation bill By Janell Cole The Forum - March 18, 2003
BISMARCK
-- All North Dakota school students deserve to be treated with respect,
House members heard Monday, and agreed by passing Senate Bill 2216.
"We
certainly don't need a Columbine to take place in North Dakota," said
Rep. Jon Nelson, R-Wolford.
The bill
school boards they must require respectful behavior from students and
staff.
"All
students and employees of the district, while on school property, involved
in a school-related activity or in attendance at a school-sponsored event,
conduct themselves in a manner that promotes respect for all individuals,
" the bill states.
But not
all House members wanted such a bill to become law.
"This
could be another trial lawyers' annuity,' said Rep. Frank Wald,
R-Dickinson, opposing the bill.
He and
others complained that the bill's language was too wide open and, instead
of preventing problems, could invite lawsuits.
"There's
no definition of respect. My definition of respect may certainly depart
from yours, with all due respect," he said. "I don't know why we
want this kind of thing in the Century Code."
Nelson
said the bill, as originally introduced in the Senate, could have opened
up the potential for litigation. It called for staff and students to
respect individuals regardless of people's age, color, economic status,
gender, intellectual ability, physical ability, race, religion or sexual
orientation. The Senate stripped out the specific language before it
passed the bill earlier.
Rep. Jim
Kasper, R-Fargo, asked what the penalty would be for bill violators.
Nelson
said each school board is to set its own policy for dealing with
complaints.
Rep. C.B.
"Buck" Haas, R-Taylor, a retired Dickinson school
superintendent, said, "It's about creating an environment, a climate
where every student feels safe and secure and can be themselves without
being bullied, without being harassed or intimidated by fellow classmates,
by anyone else in that setting."
Rep. Rae
Ann Kelsch, said it's too bad that a bill like SB 2216 has to be passed.
Nonetheless, school harassment and bullying are getting worse, according
to surveys of North Dakota parents and principals.
"I
don't think it's fair for students in a school to bully someone else just
because they're different, whether they be Jewish or Catholic or
Presbyterian or, the part we just don't want to talk about is, their
sexual orientation," she said.
Kelsch
said the federal "No Child Left Behind" act requires states to
provide safe schools.
The bill
passed 55-37 after a half hour debate. It now goes back to the Senate for
concurrence with House amendments.