Adoption
refusal bill OK By Janell Cole
The Forum, March 20, 2003
BISMARCK
-- A bill allowing North Dakota's adoption agencies to refuse service to
some families is constitutional, the state's attorney general says.
Supporters
of Senate Bill 2188 say it will put into law current practices, in which
private adoption agencies licensed by the state are free to pick and
choose clients.
All
adoptions in North Dakota are done through private agencies licensed by
the state. Three of the six licensed agencies are affiliated with
religious denominations and a fourth is religiously based.
The bill
says the state Department of Human Services can't deny an adoption agency
a state license on the basis of an agency's objection to placements that
violate the agency's religious or moral convictions.
Gay
families have testified against the bill, saying it is aimed at them. It
passed the Senate earlier this session and has been held up in the House
Human Services Committee awaiting Attorney General Wayne Stenehjem's
opinion.
House
Minority Leader Merle Boucher, D-Rolette, asked for the opinion on behalf
of the committee's Democrats and Rep. Mary Ekstrom, D-Fargo, who is not on
the committee.
Boucher
asked Stenehjem if all North Dakotans are "entitled to fair and equal
consideration regardless of religion, race, ethnic origin, gender, sexual
preference or physical appearance" in adoption services.
Committee
Chairwoman Rep. Clara Sue Price, R-Minot, said the committee will work on
the bill next week.
In the
opinion, released Wednesday afternoon, Stenehjem cites court cases
involving religious freedom, then writes, "By permitting
child-placing agencies to not participate in placement activities that
violate their religious or moral convictions or policies, SB 2188
permissibly accommodates the religious or moral beliefs of child-placing
agencies."
That the
state licenses the agencies doesn't enter the constitutional equation.
"A
child-placing agency's decision not to perform or participate in a
particular placement would be a decision made by the agency and not the
state," he wrote.
He also
said SB 2188 doesn't prevent potential foster or adoptive parents from
seeking services from a different agency if one turns them down.
Boucher
said the opinion was not what he had hoped to hear, but "we respect
what the attorney general tells us."