Bill worries gay
families By Janell Cole The Forum, January 22, 2003
BISMARCK –
Gay families asked legislators Tuesday to not pass a bill they say
legalizes discrimination against them should they want to adopt children.
But the
sponsor said it’s a religious freedom bill.
Senate Bill
2188 would prevent the state from denying an adoption agency license to
organizations refusing to facilitate adoptions that violate its religious
or moral convictions.
In North
Dakota, all the adoption agencies are private groups that obtain a state
license to operate. There are six such agencies, four of which are
affiliated with a religious denomination. One nondenominational agency is
inactive, said opponents of the bill.
Sen. Jerry
Klein, R-Fessenden, told the Senate Human Services Committee he sponsored
the bill because of increasing pressures around the country for adoption
agencies to conduct adoptions that violate their religious or moral
policies. The bill is not aimed at any particular group that may seek to
adopt children, he said.
“So! me
people may claim there is a hidden agenda. There is not,” he said.
“It only
preserves religious liberty. It does not prevent adopting parents from
using another agency.”
Chris
Dodson, executive director for the North Dakota Catholic Conference, said
the bill puts religious liberty into state law.
Vickie
Nixon, speaking for Equality North Dakota, a gay-lesbian rights
organization, said the bill, if passed, would legislate exclusion of gays
and lesbians from adoptions. It also would allow an agency of a Christian
denomination to refuse to handle adoptions for a Muslim family or
single-parent families. Meanwhile, she said, 400 children in North Dakota
are awaiting adoption.
Todd Berg of
Bismarck said it is already difficult to adopt. Berg, with his gay
partner, adopted a baby boy, Jensen, in 2001. The birth mother
specifically asked that her baby be adopted by a gay couple. But some
agencies only help families of their own denomination and another backed
out of working with a gay couple because of pressure from the state and
the baby’s foster family, he said. They were able to find another
agency.
The state
Human Rights Coalition also worries the bill could exclude many families
from adoptions who could be good parents, said Cheryl Bergian of Fargo.
Some
committee members seemed skeptical.
“Individuals
have a choice of where they go for these services,” said Chairwoman Judy
Lee, R-West Fargo.
“The
number of agencies is very limited,” Bergian said.
“That
doesn’t stop another agency from starting up,” said Sen. Bob Erbele,
R-Lehr.