Testimony
of Equality North Dakota in Support of
Senate Bill 2216
House
Education Committee, March 4, 2003
Good
morning, Madam Chairman and other members of the committee. My name
is Robert Uebel, and I live in Fargo. I am co-chair of Equality
North Dakota, the statewide advocacy organization for gay, lesbian,
bisexual and transgender North Dakotans, and I'm speaking today in support
of Senate Bill 2216 and the amendments offered by Sen. Christensen.
Equality
North Dakota firmly believes that all students deserve a safe school
environment in which they are free from harassment, bullying and
discrimination. We are particularly concerned that such an
environment does not yet exist for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender
youth in North Dakota schools. Far too often, verbal and physical
harassment are part of the daily school life of GLBT youth in our state.We have included written testimony from several individuals
which documents the harassment they faced in our schools and the failure
of administrators to take action to remedy the problems.
Just
as recently as a month ago, a case in Kindred, North Dakota came to light
where two individuals spoke of having been verbally harassed by a school
employee and other students for allegedly being gay.According to their complaint, the school principal failed to
adequately investigate the matter and take their reports of harassment
seriously.The former
students had to file a federal complaint before their concerns were
addressed by school officials.To
my knowledge the students were not seeking a financial settlement; they
merely wished to have the harassment and the lack of response acknowledged
and have steps taken to prevent the same thing from happening to other
students in the future.
Senate
Bill 2216, as it currently stands, does not include any specific
protection for GLBT students, since all categories which were originally
in the bill were removed in the Senate.A vague grievance procedure without enumerated categories is not
sufficient to protect GLBT students.Evidence shows that school officials often do not recognize that
anti-GLBT harassment and discrimination are unacceptable behaviors.Without specifically enumerating sexual orientation as a protected
category, many school officials may continue to believe that they do not
have a responsibility to respond to anti-GLBT harassment.Or it may be the case that teachers and administrators do not
feel comfortable and supported in responding to harassment of GLBT
students. It is conduct - failing to act or failing to act in a
reasonable manner - that opens up school districts to liability, not the
adoption of an anti-harassment policy.
There
is now extensive evidence that GLBT students are disproportionately
targeted for harassment and discrimination in our nation's schools.
The 2001 National School Climate Survey indicated that over 80% of GLBT
students reported being verbally harassed because of their sexual
orientation; nearly 70% reported feeling unsafe in school. Studies
also indicate that school officials often fail to respond to or, in some
cases, even participate in the discrimination and harassment.
The
climate of fear created may result in increased absenteeism, decreased
academic performance and increased risk of suicide. The National
School Climate Survey also found that over 30% of GLBT students had missed
at least one entire day of school in the past month because they felt
unsafe.
No
detailed statistics are available for GLBT students in North Dakota,
because, to the best of our knowledge, student surveys have not included
questions regarding sexual orientation. This fact alone shows that
the concerns of GLBT youth in North Dakota are not being adequately
addressed by our state's schools. Furthermore, North Dakota is the
only state in the country without a single high school gay-straight
student alliance.Far too
often, issues regarding sexual orientation are simply ignored in our
state, because they are seen as too controversial or too politically
unpopular.Many continue to
claim that there just aren’tmany GLBT people in North Dakota or that our call for full
equality under the law constitutes some sort of sinister “gay agenda.”
The
unsupportive attitudes many GLBT youth encounter in school only serve to
further paint North Dakota as a state which is unwelcoming to those who
are perceived as "different." Is it any wonder that GLBT
youth often see no future for themselves in North Dakota and leave the
state in droves? At a time when many in our state are looking for
ways to keep our young people here, we need to send the message in our
schools that all students are worthy of our full respect. Thank you.