Testimony Presented by
Equality North Dakota in Opposition to Senate Bill 2188
Equality North Dakota is
a statewide gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender rights organization.
We are here to voice our opposition to Senate Bill 2188. This bill gives
state-licensed agencies free reign to discriminate against adoption
applicants, with full protection of the law.
If
this bill is passed, it could mean that single persons would be taken out
of the adoption pool of prospective parents. A Christian-based agency
could refuse to place children with Muslim families. Another agency might
insist that only families with a stay-at-home mom would be considered.
Some might object to placing a child with parents of a different race. The
examples are endless.
North
Dakota has close to 400 children waiting for an adoptive family. The
majority of these children are without a permanent, stable home one to two
years before adoption. Allowing agencies to disqualify applicants based on
unlimited religious or moral views is not in the best interest of those
children waiting for a home. This bill also raises questions
regarding conflicts with federal and state constitutional protections
against the government endorsement of religion.
We
at Equality North Dakota are convinced that this bill is also aimed at
legislating the exclusion of gay and lesbian individuals and couples from
the adoption pool. A male gay couple from Bismarck adopted a baby boy
almost two years ago. Certain individuals and agencies tried diligently to
stop the adoption process. They were not successful.
There
is no scientific basis to believe that lesbians and gay men cannot be good
parents. Research shows that lesbian and gay parents are as fit,
effective, and successful as heterosexual parents. Children of gay parents
are as emotionally healthy, socially adjusted, and educationally
successful as children raised by heterosexual parents.
Many
professional psychological and child welfare groups agree that sexual
orientation is not a valid reason for excluding individuals from the
adoption pool. You were given a fact sheet with statements from six well
known mainstream organizations. You also have another fact sheet with some
statistics concerning lesbian and gay couples and children in lesbian and
gay families.
At
a time when many North Dakotans are looking for ways to make our state a
more welcoming and inviting place, this bill sends the message that
individuals who are perceived as “different” are not truly welcome and
entitled to the same rights and protections as others.
Equality
North Dakota urges the committee to recommend “Do Not Pass” on Senate
Bill 2188. Thank you.